Why didn’t the stock market go up?

You might have thought it obvious that the stock market would go down after S&P downgraded US government debt.  The bad news about US debt made investors worry, and worried investors are usually less enthusiastic about holding stocks.

But there is something wrong with this view.  Ask yourself, when fearful investors sell their stocks, what do they buy?  They sell their stocks for cash, of course; and then, being fearful, they typically want to keep the proceeds in the nearest thing to cash that pays interest: US government debt.  Thus, as investors’ demand for stocks goes down, their demand for dollars and other US liabilities goes up.  Such a surge in demand for US government debt would cause the price of US bonds to go up, which means that the interest rate on US debt would go down.  Doesn’t it seem paradoxical, that a downgrading of US government debt could cause demand for this debt to increase?

But sure enough, the New York Times described with some surprise that the United States Treasury was actually a beneficiary of the market shifts today (Aug 8), despite the downgrade of its debt, as 10-year yields fell to 2.32 percent from 2.56 percent, and the yield on the two-year Treasury note hit a record low.  Those who are worried about inflation should also notice that the decline in the stock market means that any given amount of dollars can actually buy more shares of the Dow Industrials.

So it is very difficult to see investors’ behavior today as a reaction to fears about inflationary deficits or a default on US government debt.  If serious investors were actually worried about the real value of US government liabilities then they should tend to move out of bond markets and into real investments like the stock market, which should drive stock prices up.  Such a move would help get real investment started, which would help get people back to work; but that is not what we saw today.

To understand what is really happening, we need to think more carefully about the risks that S&P was assessing.  Of course the US government as a whole cannot be incapable of paying the dollars that it owes, because the US government has the ability to print dollars itself.  So how can the S&P bond raters have any legitimate concerns about a possibility of the US government defaulting its debt obligations?  The answer is that a default could happen only if one part of the US government prevented other parts from paying the bills.

The bills of the US government are paid by the Treasury Department, but the ability to print dollars is vested in the Federal Reserve.  The Treasury can get new dollars by issuing bonds that are purchased by the Federal Reserve.  But, although the bonds in such a transaction would be held by the government itself, they would still be counted in the aggregate debt that is restricted by Congress’s debt limit.  So when the US Congress refused to raise the debt limit, it was threatening to prevent the Treasury and Federal Reserve from working together to pay for the government’s budgeted expenses and debt obligations.  In a situation like that, the President would indeed have to choose between cutting budgeted government expenses or asking the bond holders to wait.

We have seen, however, that the investors’ movement from stocks to bonds today is very hard to reconcile with fears of default on these bonds.  So to explain the stock market decline, we have to look at the other side of the story, the very real possibility that a politically constrained US government might have to cut expenses for essential government services.  Broad fears of a crippled US government that is unable to enforce laws or invest in infrastructure could do very serious damage to investment and economic growth in America.  Indeed the possibility of such government paralysis could be far more economically damaging than any marginal increase in taxes.

Thus, there is every reason to believe that investors are reacting, not to fears of too much government debt, but to fears of too little government spending where it is needed.  Investors are expressing fears that the US government may become unable to do its essential part in maintaining the strength of this country.  Pundits and congressmen should take note.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: